As kids, we used to beg our parents to take us to the local creamery for ice cream with the neighbor kids, and an ice cream cake to celebrate a birthday was an even more exciting surprise. Imagine being that age and finding out you could rent out the whole ice cream parlor and be surrounded by only your friends? Buying out this NYC hotspot is basically the grown up version of that sugar-filled childhood dream come to life. And so, we’re adding Morgenstern’s to our #birthdaybucketlist for the kid in all of us.