Baron's Cove
4 stars
8.7
Very good
(277)
4 stars
Updating price...

Baron's Cove

4 stars
31 West Water Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
8.7
Very good
277 reviews
Updating price...

Overview

Rating
Hotel in Sag Harbor with free valet parking and a fitness center Along with a restaurant, this smoke-free hotel has a fitness center and a bar/lounge. Free WiFi in public areas and free valet parking are also provided. Other amenities include a snackExpedia Group
Hotel in Sag Harbor with free valet parking and a fitness center Along with a restaurant, this smoke-free hotel has a fitness center and a bar/lounge. Free WiFi in public areas and free valet parking are also provided. Other amenities include a snack bar/deli, a coffee shop/cafe, and massage/treatment rooms. Baron's Cove offers 67 air-conditioned accommodations, which are accessible via exterior corridors and feature iPod docking stations and espresso makers. Tempur-Pedic beds feature Egyptian cotton sheets and down comforters. 48-inch flat-screen televisions come with premium cable channels and pay movies. Bathrooms include bathtubs or showers, bathrobes, designer toiletries, and complimentary toiletries. Guests can surf the web using the complimentary wireless Internet access (speed: 100+ Mbps (good for 1–2 people or up to 6 devices)). Business-friendly amenities include safes and phones. Additionally, rooms include complimentary bottled water and hair dryers. In-room massages and hypo-allergenic bedding can be requested. A nightly turndown service is provided and housekeeping is offered daily. Recreational amenities at the hotel include a fitness center, a seasonal outdoor pool, and complimentary bicycles. The recreational activities listed below are available either on site or nearby; fees may apply.Expedia Group
Rating
8.7
Very good
Based on 277 verified guest reviews

Available rates

Sun 5/18
Mon 5/19

The neighborhood

31 West Water Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

What's nearby

  • Sag Harbor Whaling Museum5 min walk
  • Old Whalers Church8 min walk
  • Bay Street Theatre6 min walk
  • First Presbyterian Church10 min walk

Reviews

8.7
Very good
277 verified ratings
Wonderful
148
Very good
49
Good
37
Okay
16
Fair
10
Mediocre
6
Poor
11

Summary of reviews

Guests say
Guests appreciated the hotel's cleanliness and great location, often highlighting the charming atmosphere and thoughtful details in service. However, many reviews pointed out issues with customer service, including unresponsive staff and poor handling of check-in. Noise levels were also a concern for some guests, affecting their overall experience.
AI-Generated from customer reviews
Cleanliness9 out of 10
Location8.5 out of 10
Atmosphere8 out of 10
Noise Level3 out of 10
Service2.5 out of 10
Sort by:Most recent

Filters

Review rating
Traveler type
Time of year

Score by provider

All reviews

10
Wonderful
Nicola, May 2025
Pros (+) Friendly staff - perfect location - very good food.
8.0
Very good
Nina, May 2025
Pros (+) All fabulous
Cons (-) Size of room and some floor rugs. And for the price and level of accommodation showers should have a handheld as well as shower head.
8.0
Very good
Linda, Apr 2025
Pros (+) Gorgeous hotel. Rooms were large and comfy. Beds were so comfortable. Restaurant was superb, I highly recommend both breakfast and dinner. Village was a short walk away and location was perfect! Lovely products in the bathroom that added a touch of luxury and were gratefully used.
Cons (-) Showers were half screened so could get a bit messy in the bathroom with water pouring out while having a shower. Teeny fridge in the room, would have liked it a bit bigger.
8.0
Very good
Sekip, Apr 2025
Pros (+) Comfortable, quiet, clean room.
Cons (-) TV is not capable of using streaming services.
10
Wonderful
Katie, Mar 2025
Pros (+) This is one of mine and my husband's favorite spots. We tend to visit places off-season because we enjoy the quiet and less crowds. So I can say parking and prices were good, but again, it's off season. However, the experience, accommodations and attentiveness of the staff is fantastic and I am sure it is even in the height of the season!
9.0
Wonderful
Nicole, Feb 2025
Pros (+) The property was clean, staff was friendly and it was decorated nicely . The location to the town and other areas like Montauk, The Hamptons and Shelter island was also a plus.
Cons (-) Nothing
7.0
Good
Juliette, Jan 2025
Pros (+) The lobby & bar were beautifully decorated for Christmas as well as the exterior of the building.
Cons (-) The heater was very very loud when it clicked on. You either had to freeze or if you had it set at a low/reasonable temp (65 for us when we sleep) it constantly clicked on & woke me which was irritating. I didn't sleep great & rarely have a night away from my kids
8.0
Very good
Azin, Dec 2024
Pros (+) The layout and location
Cons (-) Very dark. No light. Not enough room at the bar. Bar seats were not comfortable
10
Wonderful
Diana, Dec 2024
Pros (+) staff was trying to make the stay very pleasant; breakfast was great
8.0
Very good
Denise, Nov 2024
Pros (+) location was great, music in bar was great
Cons (-) The bartender never smiled; didn't acknowledge me. He seemed like he hated his job.

Amenities

  • Private beach
  • Outdoor pool
  • Fitness center
  • Restaurant
  • Bar/Lounge
  • Room service
  • Free Wi-Fi
  • Valet parking
  • Free parking
  • Shuttle service (free)

Things to keep in mind

Check-in: From 4:00 pm
Check-out: Prior to 12:00 pm
Cancellation/prepayment
Cancellation/prepayment policies vary by room type and provider.